SWELL at Charlatan: Four Bodies, Yet Five on Stage

By Koen Dignef | October 23, 2026. English translation of the review originally published by Dansende Beren.

One of the absolute best unknown lo-fi bands ever is, without a doubt, California’s Swell. Unfortunately, the group has remained a (too) well-kept secret. To be honest, we were incredibly surprised to learn that the quartet would be performing right here in our home town of Ghent. And to be even more honest, seeing the band live has been a dream of ours for a very long time. We never thought Swell would ever perform again because original mastermind David Freel journeyed to the place and time from which no one returns in 2022. Drummer and co-founder Sean Kirkpatrick didn’t want the group’s fantastic music to fade away and found fellow musicians with the same idea in (ex-)member John Dettman on vocals and guitar, Tim Adams on bass, and Belgian Philippe Gunst on guitar and keys. If you don’t know the band, do yourself a massive favor and put on their records …Well? from 1992 and 41 from 1994. Swell never achieved commercial success, and while we don’t like using big words, that is frankly just a shame and a disgrace. Oh well, it is what it is. It’s one of the few bands we are truly proud to know and occasionally pull out to show off. Why? Simply because they are good.

Bergaf provided the support act, which was a great choice as they are a trio making songs in 2026 that could easily fit into Sonic Youth’s catalog, for example. It also works out nicely that Philippe Gunst plays (temporarily?) with Swell while drummer Astrid Van Ingelgom plays in Bergaf. And let those two also be band members of Fragment. There you go, that’s the first circle closed. And the performance itself? A broken bike chain meant we could only catch a few songs by the band. Upon entering the venue—exhausted and a bit pissed off—we heard Sonic Youth’s “Mildred Pierce”? The evening’s finale was the blistering “Samantha,” where the three musicians thrashed their instruments fiercely, reminding us just how capable this trio is of turning up the heat. We’ve resolved to check out Bergaf live somewhere in Flanders soon. We are definitely intrigued. Damn chain.

The band members of Swell were already on stage around quarter past nine setting up their instruments, testing cables, plugging in pedalboards, and setting up cymbals. We saw that Tim Adams was having some trouble with his cute, ruler-sized keyboard, and the staff from Democrazy / Charlatan opened up the toy, but help and reanimation could no longer save it. So no synth(ie), and original drummer/band member Sean Kirkpatrick would apologize profusely later because the sound would be slightly different as a result. But honestly, not a single person minded for even a second. As a quick side note: the organization’s staff were extremely helpful the whole time, treating Swell’s quartet like royalty, which deserves to be mentioned. Swell mostly drew from the catalog of the aforementioned records from the first paragraph. Dressed entirely and completely in black, the band started with the almost sinister “Is That Important?”, where guitarist Dettman first plays the same hypnotic riff for a full minute until everything erupts. We immediately felt that this is a band that wears lo-fi like armor, and “At Long Last” followed right away as the second track. Look, we’re biased because we love Swell to bits, but the sound was truly top-notch!

First off, Kirkpatrick is a very special drummer who plays delightfully wacky fills—fills that fit perfectly with the strange melodies that the late David Freel held a patent on. But the grand prize for both the band and the audience was undoubtedly the addition of Philippe Gunst on electric guitar. In Swell, Dettman plays an amplified acoustic guitar, but it’s always those quirky little guitar embellishments that make the band’s sound so special and even unique. And Gunst played them to perfection! At times, it felt as though we were listening to the records themselves while still smelling the sweat of a live gig. In our notebook, next to Gunst’s name, we wrote: Top squared.

It didn’t quite hit us at first, but behind Kirkpatrick’s drums, grayscale photos depicting American scenes were occasionally projected. Sometimes the album titles were flashed, and once we even thought we saw an image of the lamented Freel appearing to walk right out of the canvas. And that, right there, is the beauty of this Swell tour: the fact that the music can still be played because this quartet remains open to it. Okay, Freel is gone, but that doesn’t mean his entire body of work has to be buried with him, and these four musicians have understood that very well. “It’s OK” opens with that driving bass, and the drum rolls sound ominous and menacing until those guitars finally burst open. For anyone reading this article who doesn’t know the band, put this track on! It truly is a magnificent experience.

As mentioned, they mostly drew from those two monumental records from 1992 and 1993, and from 41 they played “Song Seven,” “Kinda Stoned,” and “Smile My Friend” back-to-back. Sure, things went slightly awry here and there with a drum hit coming in a fraction too late or a chord not quite landing right, and of course Adams’s synth giving up the ghost, but that was precisely the cool part of the entire show. This isn’t some polished epic fed to you on a silver platter, but rather a loose stack of pages spat together with saliva. The crazy thing about Swell is that we feel they are a band meant for venues like Trix or AB, but they might be just a bit too unconventional and unknown for that. They remain a cult band, but one that knows how to carry a crowd. Evidence of this was the song “Sunshine, Everyday,” which was sung along by the entire audience. The charismatic Dettman simply raised his arm briefly, and everyone knew they were allowed to join in. It created a bond between the band and the audience, making it even more of a show you were thrilled to be a part of.

Kirkpatrick came forward and spoke very sincerely about his love for his departed friend. They had made music together, lived together, and shared love and hardship. It was striking to see Kirkpatrick still talking about his best buddy with the utmost respect and the heaviest sense of loss. Dettman admitted that he had learned everything from Freel and felt it a huge honor to step into his shoes. It wasn’t an act, it wasn’t playacting; it was a heartfelt tribute to a human being they loved dearly. It was touching and beautiful when Dettman handed Kirkpatrick a small candle to give the moment extra resonance. For a brief instant, the audience held its breath because we all know people we miss. “What I Always Wanted” and “Bridgette, You Love Me” closed out this brilliant performance. They also played a few songs from Too Many Days Without Thinking from 1997, another very strong record by the band. Look, for us, a childhood dream has come true: seeing Swell perform live! We came home and our wife said we were glowing. She’s right. It was, after all, a wonderfully beautiful concert in a truly wonderful venue. Everything clicked tonight. Swell stood with four bodies on stage, but they were clearly five. Can we see the dead? Certainly, because we just saw David Freel perform.

Swell will continue touring Europe for a while and has added new dates for shows in the Low Countries: Antwerp and Oostende in Belgium, Sittard and Breda in the Netherlands. Everything is neatly listed on Swell’s website.

Setlist

Is That Important?
At Long Last
Love You All
Down
Forget About Jesus
It’s OK
Everything
Song Seven
Kinda Stoned
Smile My Friend
Tired
Get High
Sunshine, Everyday
What I Always Wanted
Bridgette, You Love Me

Read the original article in Dutch at Dansende Beren.